• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation

DAVID GILCHRIST AUTHOR

Epic Fantasy Author

  • Home
  • About the Author
  • Books
    • The Risen God
    • Tapasya
    • Pyrite
    • Prasad
    • Nikka
    • The Lyrat Pair
  • Writer’s Blogk
  • Contact
  • Writer’s Blogk
    • Author’s Desk
    • The Next Epic
    • Making Paths
    • Fantasy Musings
    • Guest Adventurers
    • Book Reviews
    • Side Quests
    • Uncategorized

Book Reviews

Book Review: The White Plague

March 20, 2016 by David Gilchrist

Finished listening to The White Plague by Frank Herbert.  Yes, another Frank Herbert book.  This one ain’t part of the Dune cannon this time, just a stand alone job.

Rough plot synopsis: An IRA bomb kills the wife and children of a brilliant bio scientist. He suffers a psychological episode due to this and decides to design a plague.  He decides to target this genetically engineered disease to affect only females.  Then he unleashes the virus in three places: Ireland, Libya and the USA.

Once released, the plague kills most of the woman on the planet, spreading beyond the limits of the original scheme.

The book follows the decent of the protagonist ( John ) as he flicks between the personalities he has created.

All in all, it’s a strange book.  There’s enough technical detail in the genetics to please fans of hard sci-fi (but what else would you expect from the man who wrote Dune). There’s a hint of horror too, almost reminiscent of his namesake James Herbert.  And there’s a good slice of psychological thriller to it, with all the political shenanigans of the cold war era in which it was set played out in all its gory details.

So why, with all this going for it, does it leave me so dissatisfied?

Maybe it’s because its a little of all these things that it doesn’t hit the mark with any of them.  Some of the technical stuff now comes across as a bit preposterous ( he uses a new fangled computer at one point, whatever that is). The horror of the plague never fully comes across (compare this with, for example some of James Herbert early works, The Rats or The Dark).

Its not a book I’ll go back and read, but I’m glad I gave it a shot. There’s some very good writing and the story has resonance with the present day.

Filed Under: Book Reviews Tagged With: #bookreview

Book reviews – Prelude to Dune series:

March 10, 2016 by David Gilchrist

Dune_atreides

Despite saying that I was pretty fed-up after finishing the original Dune series ( Dune – Chapterhouse Dune), I ended up listening to the prelude series (all 3 books) in the past month.

To be honest they were quite a pleasant surprise.  Co-written by Frank Herbert’s son Brian and Kevin J Anderson, they detail the events in the run up to the original novel.

All in all they are a fairly decent, well-written sci-fi novels.  I can understand why fans of the original Dune novels might find them disappointing.  Where the original develops a new world, new ideas and explores its boundaries, a prelude is by its very nature, tied into those same the predefined limits.

The good thing about that is that the story is freed up from the burden of world-building (although it must make some effort to break new ground).  The bad news is that it can leave the story feeling a little superficial – less epic in scope.

I guess they could be read on their own, but I wouldn’t miss out on the original novel.

That put to one side, the story of the rise and fall of the great houses in the Imperium makes for a very entertaining read.

Filed Under: Book Reviews Tagged With: #bookreview, #sci-fi

Copyright © 2025 · David Gilchrist - Epic Fantasy Author · Log in